Well, this worked out much better than I thought it was going to. Last night was the second night that James slept in the big boy bed in his brother's room, instead of the crib in his old room. On Tuesday night we went out for dinner and when we got home Mike decided to put James in the big boy bed in Charlie's room. James went straight to sleep. Last night after cleaning up the huge mess the boys had made I put James in his new bed and he went straight to sleep again. Charlie went to bed later and managed to keep quiet and not wake his brother. All in all this has been great experience and a bit surprising...in a good way!!